Tuesday, January 31, 2017

In Which "The Lying Detective" Bums Me Out

via
So Sherlock season four came out.

I didn’t like it. I won’t go into all the reasons why, since spoilers are unfashionable and Sherlock doesn’t deserve that much of my energy anyway. Still, one aspect of Episode 2, “The Lying Detective” just bugged me.

That aspect is called Sherlock’s drug use.

For those who haven’t seen the episode (and in the least spoilery summary possible), the gist is that John is mad at Sherlock, so Sherlock takes SO MUCH COCAINE that he is literally weeks from death. By the end, we find out that Sherlock’s dangerous drug use was a ploy to trick John into rescuing Sherlock from the bad guy and himself. John then realizes how silly he was to be mad at Sherlock and they live happily ever after. The end.

Problematic much?

To be clear, it is not so much the cocaine that bothers me. The canonical Sherlock Holmes dabbled in cocaine, and most other Sherlocks do, too. I’m reluctant to say cocaine is “fine,” but last semester I read High Price by Dr. Carl Hart—it addressed harmful assumptions about drugs and racism in the United States, so I don’t want to perpetuate those. Suffice it to say that while cocaine can bring iffy baggage with it, there are totally ways to do Sherlock Holmes that incorporate his drug use and are still awesome. (Plenty of renditions have already succeeded—I love Elementary and the Robert Downey Jr. movies. A Study in Charlotte by Brittany Cavallaro comes to mind as well.)

“Sherlock uses cocaine.” Whatever.

“Sherlock uses cocaine to destroy himself and manipulate his best friend.” How ‘bout no.

There are psychological rules for what counts as manipulation. This might not meet that definition. Nor was this exceptionally odd for Sherlock. We know Sherlock nearly kills himself over his cases more than is healthy. And I’m sure there are people out there who found “The Lying Detective” perfectly acceptable—to be fair, it was much better than its predecessor. Shouldn’t we leave room for drama? Don’t we want to see Holmes and Watson at their limits?

I’m not going to say no. But I am going to say that Sherlock played with John’s brain. Even if he had good-ish intentions (don’t think Mary is off the hook for all of this), this was a plan to get what Sherlock wanted—not necessarily what John wanted, or even needed. Respect for John’s time, emotions, and even safety were thrown out the window.

Sherlock invaded John’s boundaries. Sherlock forced John to be responsible for his life—if John never stepped in, Sherlock would have died. It would be “John’s fault.” Which means Sherlock essentially threatened to kill himself to maintain their relationship. I don’t count that as a good thing.

via
Friendships are demanding things. You have to give and take, and sometimes it sucks, and sometimes it is beyond rewarding. Sherlock Holmes, if nothing else, is a demanding person. Part of the joy in watching Sherlock Holmes stories, for me, is getting to see what Sherlock and Watson give to one another. Their friendship is infamous not because of their similarities, but their complementary natures. And we’ve had over 100 years to consider the ways their friendship can fail… but also why it always rises victorious.

I struggle with the end of this episode. John was mad at Sherlock for a silly reason, so some element of forgiveness was necessary. But good friends also don’t abuse drugs to resolve their disagreements. Not like Sherlock did. That was a breach of trust, and so I’m still kind of mad about what that behavior took away from the friendship. How can John really trust Sherlock after that? BBC Sherlock shouldn’t make it harder and harder for me to say that Holmes and Watson are an amazing team, but it seems like each new season proves me wrong.

What did you think of BBC Sherlock season four?

8 comments :

  1. Ugh. I watched episode 1 of season 4 and got so mad that I didn't bother watching the rest of the season. I might come back to it, but this sounds awful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I feel you on that front. XD I would have done the same if I weren't so darn curious. The second episode is better than the first, but the third might be even worse. So... yeah. Blah.

      Delete
  2. I kind of wanted to cry after watching the first episode of season 4. It just wasn't as good as the first 3?? I love Sherlock so much, and my expectations were sky high.

    I didn't even notice the drug issue, to be honest, so blinded I was by trying to reconcile the new season with the past 3. Great post, and excellent point!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know. I mean, I've even become disenchanted by the third season... It just did not end up in as good a place as it started.

      I'm glad it gave you something new to think about! But yeah. This season was a bit of a shock. In a bad way.

      Delete
  3. I haven't watched this season yet, but this is a really important post. I think it's easy to let misrepresentations or things that we disagree with in media we consume go, especially since *we* consume a lot of media. Being thoughtful about what you're actually letting in your head requires effort, but it's important.
    Or maybe we can just learn not to kill ourselves for the sake of being saved by our friends. UGH.
    This was super insightful as usual :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *nods* That's a good point—the sheer amount of stuff we read and watch can make it seem like one individual show doesn't matter that much in the grand scheme of things. And yet it does!

      Thanks for reading, Shar!

      Delete
  4. I've never watched Sherlock, so I don't have much to say about this...But manipulating people is not okay, and doing it by risking yourself is even worse. But thanks for the thoughtful post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *nods* I'm glad you agree, and sincerely hope none of your friends ever do this to you. :) Thanks for commenting!

      Delete

Check it out, comments and stuff. I love to hear from readers, and I always respond to commenters! Here's the fun part—if you leave a link to your blog I'll show up and comment back. I have just one rule down here: Don't Be a Problem. This spans the entire umbrella of rudeness and crudeness, so I reiterate: Don't Be a Problem. Thanks for stopping by!